Physics · Unit 6: Optics ·  Project 6-1-4

Deep Dive: Designing and Testing an Optical Device

🔬 Deep Dive
This is your textbook for this topic. Read it before you build.
AConcept

A Device Is a Spec You Can Test

“It works” isn’t something you can measure. A spec is a requirement written as a number you can check. A good spec has three parts: the quantity, the target, and the way you will measure it. Compare:

VagueA real spec
“A good periscope.”“Raises the line of sight 0.30 m; the exit ray is parallel to the entering ray within 2°.”
“A strong magnifier.”“Magnification at least 4×, measured with two rulers.”
“A telescope that works.”“M at least 4×, a tube of 60 cm or less, and brick mortar visible at 8 m.”

Engineers follow the same loop every time: spec → predict → build → measure → compare. You predict first, so that when you measure, the difference between the two numbers actually tells you something. If you only measure afterward, any result looks fine. The gap between prediction and measurement is the real result, and it points you to the part of the build that needs work.

🔑Report your gap as a percent error: |measured − predicted| ÷ measured × 100. It lets a reader decide at a glance whether your prediction was good, and it forces you to explain the difference instead of hiding it.
BMath

Designing a Periscope

A periscope is two flat mirrors, each set at 45° to the light path. The first turns the beam by 90° and the second turns it back. The vertical distance between the mirrors is how much the line of sight is raised, so a 0.30 m raise needs mirrors 0.30 m apart.

What makes it work is that the mirrors are parallel to each other. From Activity 6-1-1, two mirrors turn a ray by a total of 2α, where α is the angle between them. For a periscope you want that to be zero, so the exiting beam travels in exactly the direction it entered:

ray error = 2 × (angle between the mirrors) miss = L × tan(error)
How parallel is parallel enough?
Given
  • The beam must land within 5.0 cm of the target on a wall 2.0 m away
Solve
Allowed ray error = tan⁻¹(0.050 ÷ 2.0) = 1.43°
Allowed angle between the mirrors = 1.43° ÷ 2 = 0.72°
Check: 1.5° out of parallel gives an error of 3.0°, and a miss of 2.0 × tan 3.0° = 10.5 cm. That fails.
✓ The mirrors need to be within about 0.7° of parallel. That’s tighter than it sounds, and it is why you check alignment with a laser instead of by eye.
💡Notice what doesn’t matter: if both mirrors are tilted the same way, the direction of the exiting beam doesn’t change. A periscope’s mirrors don’t have to be exactly 45°. They have to match each other. (A common tilt does shift the beam sideways a little, but the angle between the mirrors is what steers it.)

Two more design points. First, a 45° mirror stretches a beam, so for a tube of width w, each mirror must be at least 1.4 × w long, or it will clip the picture. A 4.0 cm wide tube needs mirrors at least 5.7 cm long. Second, you can replace each mirror with a 45° right-angle prism: light hits the long face at 45°, which is more than the 42° critical angle of glass or acrylic, so it reflects totally (Activity 6-1-2), with no silver coating to wear off. Household mirrors reflect only about 85–90% of the light, so a two-mirror periscope passes about 70–80%.

A periscope keeps the image upright. Two reflections undo each other’s left-right reversal, so unlike a single mirror, what you see through it isn’t mirror-imaged.

CExample

Periscope Alignment Explorer

Start with mirror 1 at 0° and mirror 2 at 1.5°. Then tilt both by the same amount and watch the direction error disappear. Then move them in opposite directions and watch it double.

A beam enters a periscope from the left, bounces off two mirrors, and heads for a wall. Each slider tilts one mirror away from a perfect 45°. (The tilts are drawn to scale in angle, but the distances are not.)

walltargetbeam inmirror 2mirror 1
Angle between the mirrors = 1.5°
Ray error = 2 × 1.5° = 3.0°
Miss at 2.0 m = 2.0 × tan 3.0° = 10.5 cm
More than 5 cm off. Bring the two mirrors closer to parallel.
DMath

Designing and Measuring a Magnifier

A magnifier is one converging lens with the object held at, or just inside, its focal length. What a magnifier does is make the object subtend a bigger angle at your eye, which is called angular magnification. Compared with looking at the object from the closest comfortable distance of 25 cm, a lens of focal length f gives about

M ≈ 25 cm ÷ f

A shorter focal length means a stronger lens and more magnification, but it also means you have to hold the lens closer to the object and you see a smaller patch of it. “Bigger” isn’t automatically “better.”

Choosing a lens for 8×
Given
  • You want M = 8×
Solve
f = 25 ÷ M = 25 ÷ 8 = 3.1 cm
Power = 1 ÷ 0.031 m = 32 D
✓ You need a lens with a focal length of about 3.1 cm, a fairly strong lens, which means a small, steeply curved one.

How to measure M. You can’t read magnification off the lens, but you can measure it with two millimeter rulers. Put one ruler under the lens, and hold the other 25 cm from your free eye. With both eyes open, your brain overlays the two views. If 1 mm of the magnified ruler spans N mm of the unaided ruler, then M = N. Repeat it a few times and average.

Reading the two-ruler comparison
Given
  • 1 mm of the magnified ruler lines up with 4.4 mm of the unaided ruler on average
  • The lens measured f = 5.2 cm
Solve
Measured M = 4.4×
Predicted M = 25 ÷ 5.2 = 4.8×
Percent error = |4.4 − 4.8| ÷ 4.4 × 100 = 9%
✓ The magnifier delivers 4.4×, about 9% below the prediction, which is a reasonable agreement for a hand-held lens measured by eye.
EMath

Designing and Measuring a Telescope

A simple telescope has two converging lenses. The objective, with a long focal length, makes a small real image of a faraway scene at its focal point. The eyepiece, with a short focal length, works as a magnifier on that image. The magnification is the ratio of the focal lengths:

M = f_objective ÷ f_eyepiece

For the eyepiece to work as a magnifier, it must sit one of its focal lengths past the objective’s image. For a faraway object that image is one objective focal length behind the objective, so the tube length is

length ≈ f_objective + f_eyepiece

The image you see is inverted, which doesn’t matter for this project. A wider objective collects more light, so the view is brighter, while a higher magnification gives a narrower, dimmer, shakier view.

Why the tube has to slide

A nearby object isn’t at infinity, so the objective’s image doesn’t form at its focal point. From the lens equation, it forms at d_i = f_o d_o ÷ (d_o − f_o), a little farther back. The eyepiece has to follow it.

Focusing on a nearby object
Given
  • f_objective = 40 cm, f_eyepiece = 10 cm
  • The object is 10 m (1000 cm) away
Solve
d_i = (40 × 1000) ÷ (1000 − 40) = 41.7 cm
Tube length = 41.7 + 10 = 51.7 cm (compared with 50 cm for a faraway object)
The eyepiece has to slide back 1.7 cm
✓ For a nearby target the telescope has to be about 1.7 cm longer than for a distant one. Build it so the eyepiece can slide.

How to measure M. Aim at a regular pattern such as bricks or a ruled sheet 8–10 m away. Look through the telescope with one eye while the other eye looks at the same pattern unaided. With both eyes open, count how many unaided-eye bricks fit across one brick in the telescope’s view. That count is M.

A telescope check
Given
  • Objective f = 41.0 cm and eyepiece f = 9.8 cm (both measured)
  • One brick in the telescope’s view spans 3.8 unaided bricks
Solve
Predicted M = 41.0 ÷ 9.8 = 4.18×
Measured M = 3.8×
Percent error = |3.8 − 4.18| ÷ 3.8 × 100 = 10%
✓ The telescope delivers about 3.8×, 10% below the prediction. That narrowly misses a 4× spec, and the focal-length measurements are the first place to look.
FExample

Telescope Planner

Try combinations until you find one that meets a 4× spec and a 60 cm tube. Then slide the object closer and see how much longer the tube has to get.

Choose an objective and an eyepiece, and see the magnification and the tube length you need. Then pick how far away the object is, and watch the eyepiece have to slide back for nearby things.

imageobjective 40 cmeyepiece 10 cmlength = 50.0 cm
Object distance:
M = 40 ÷ 10 = 4.0×
Tube length = 40 + 10 = 50.0 cm
This design meets a 4× spec and fits in a 60 cm tube. The image is inverted.
GConcept

Proving It in a Demo

A good demo makes the measurement visible. In 60–90 seconds, cover these in order:

  1. The claim. Say what the device is and state its spec, with the numbers.
  2. The device in action. Show it doing its job, such as reading a letter, resolving the bricks, or putting the laser on the target.
  3. The measurement, on camera. Show the laser dot on the wall, the two rulers overlaid, or the brick count.
  4. The comparison. State the predicted value, the measured value, and the percent error.
  5. The honest part. Say where the gap came from and what you’d change.
💡A device that meets its spec by 1% and a device that misses by 10% can both earn full credit, if the measurement is real and the explanation is honest. What you can’t do is show a device and say “it works” without a number.
HWatch Out

Three Common Mix-Ups

⚠️“Higher magnification is always better.” It isn’t. More magnification narrows the field of view, dims the image, and makes every wobble bigger. Choose the magnification your task needs, and no more.
⚠️“Each periscope mirror has to be at exactly 45°.” 45° is what turns the beam 90°, but the direction of the exiting beam depends on how parallel the two mirrors are to each other. A pair tilted the same way still sends the beam straight on.
⚠️“The telescope tube is just a case.” The tube sets the spacing between the lenses, and the spacing is a design parameter. Get it wrong by a centimeter or two and the image goes soft, which is why the eyepiece has to slide.
IConcept

Quick Check

Four questions. They are not graded. Answer them to find out what still needs work.

Q1The two mirrors in a periscope are 2.0° out of parallel. How far off course is the exiting ray?
Q2A telescope has an objective with f = 50 cm and an eyepiece with f = 10 cm. What are its magnification and its length for a faraway object?
Q3A magnifier lens has f = 4.0 cm. About what is its magnification?
Q4Why must the eyepiece of a telescope slide back a little to focus on a nearby object?
Score: 0 of 4
JConcept

Looking Ahead

You’ve now designed, built, and measured an optical device. Next you’ll do the design half on paper, for a real person with a real need and a real limit on size or cost.

← Back to Project 6-1-4Go to the Project →